Regret having eyelid surgery? How to tell what’s normal during recovery and what isn’t

You may have been looking forward to it for years: no more heavy eyelids and a fresher look. Then, a few days after surgery, you look in the mirror and are shocked. Your eyelids are swollen and blue, one eye seems bigger than the other, and you wonder what you’ve got yourself into. Many people have that thought during the first week.

Often, regret comes from seeing your eyes while they are still healing. Sometimes there is more to it. In this blog, you’ll learn what to expect at each stage of recovery, which symptoms usually go away on their own and when it’s best to call us straight away. You’ll also learn what you can do if you’re still unhappy months later, and how to reduce the chance of regret beforehand.

Why it’s so common to regret your decision in the first few weeks

During eyelid surgery, the doctor removes excess skin from the upper eyelid and sometimes a little fat or muscle too. It is a real operation, even though you will usually have only a local anaesthetic and go home the same day. Afterward, the tissue needs time to heal. Swelling, bruising and a tight feeling are normal at first.


Your eyes often look their worst during those weeks. Swelling is rarely the same on both sides, so your eyes may temporarily look uneven. The crease in your eyelid—the line where the lid folds when your eye is open—may look higher or sharper than you expected. So don’t judge the result too soon.


Emotions play a part too. You’ve spent money, changed your appearance, and you don’t look your best for a while. It’s very common to feel low during the first week. It doesn’t mean anything is wrong. Discuss your concerns with your clinic; that’s the most helpful thing to do at this stage.


What happens next? A Dutch study involving more than 2,100 people gives a good picture. Six months after upper eyelid surgery, they were significantly more satisfied with their eyes and eyelids than before. On average, they felt they looked more than three years younger. They still felt the same way after a year.

Close-up van een oog met het bovenooglid

What’s normal, from day one to a year later

Everyone’s recovery is different. This timeline gives a general idea of what to expect after upper eyelid surgery. Always follow your own surgeon’s aftercare instructions.


Days 1 to 3. Swelling and bruising often get worse before they get better. Your eyelids feel tight and puffy. Your eyes may water or feel dry, and ointment or drops may make your vision a little blurry. Cold compresses can help, as can sleeping with your head slightly elevated.


Days 4 to 7. Stitches are usually removed between days 5 and 7. The swelling starts to go down. The incision is still red and clearly visible.


Week 2. Most of the bruising has faded and many people are back at work. Your eyelid may still feel a little stiff, and the crease may still look high or sharp.


Weeks 3 to 6. The remaining swelling gradually goes down. Any difference between the left and right sides usually becomes less noticeable. During these weeks, the scar may be pink and slightly raised.


Months 3 to 6. All the swelling is gone and the eyelid has settled. The scar becomes flatter and lighter. Only now can you properly assess whether this is what you wanted.


Six months to a year. The scar continues to fade and soften gradually. If a revision is needed, your doctor will assess this during this period.


For patients at Cosmopolitan Clinic, swelling and bruising usually disappear within one to two weeks, and the incision is well healed after about six weeks. You won’t see the final result until three to six months.

These symptoms are a reason to call immediately

Most symptoms after eyelid surgery are uncomfortable but harmless. A few warning signs are not.


Go to the emergency department immediately or call 112 if your vision gets worse after surgery, or if you have severe pain with an eye that bulges forward or an eyelid that swells up hard and tight. Call your clinic on the way. This is rare, but it is an emergency. It usually happens within the first 24 to 48 hours after surgery.


Call your clinic the same day, or the out-of-hours GP service outside office hours, if you experience:


  • pain that gets worse instead of better, or pain with nausea or vomiting;
  • double vision, even after blinking or once the ointment has worn off, or difficulty moving an eye;
  • bleeding from the incision that doesn’t stop after ten to fifteen minutes of gentle pressure;
  • fever, pus, or redness that spreads and feels warm;
  • an incision that opens;
  • an eye that doesn’t close properly and becomes painful, red or blurry.

  • Research suggests that serious bleeding behind the eye occurs in about one in every 2,000 eyelid surgeries. Vision loss is even rarer: about one in every 20,000. Permanent vision loss occurs in about one in every 30,000 cases. If this type of bleeding occurs, acting quickly can save your sight.

    Too much or too little skin removed

    A common complaint after eyelid surgery is that too little or too much skin was removed.


    Too little skin removed. After a few months, you may still see a fold hanging over your eyelashes, or the change may be less noticeable than you’d hoped. In a study by the American Mayo Clinic, a second operation was needed after 3.8 percent of upper eyelid surgeries. In most cases, too much skin was left behind. This is easy to address: the surgeon can remove another small strip of skin.


    Too much skin removed. Your eyelid may feel tight, or your eye may no longer close fully (lagophthalmos). This is less common, but harder to correct. That’s why a surgeon would rather remove a little too little than too much. If too much fat is also removed, the eye socket can look hollow. In the first few weeks, an eye that doesn’t close fully is usually due to swelling and resolves on its own. If your eye still doesn’t close fully after a few months, too much skin or muscle may have been removed, or the scar may be pulling. Have a specialist assess it.

    Uneven eyes and an eyelid crease that doesn’t sit right

    No face is perfectly symmetrical. One eyebrow is often a little higher than the other, or one eyelid is heavier. After surgery, this may suddenly become noticeable because the skin that was hiding the difference has been removed.


    In the first few weeks, unevenness is usually caused by swelling. One eye heals faster than the other. A crease that looks high, sharp or uneven usually softens over the following months too. Read on to find out how to track this with photos.


    If the eyelid itself sits too low, removing skin won’t fix it. Usually, the tendon of the muscle that lifts the eyelid has stretched or come loose. This is called ptosis, or a drooping eyelid, and requires a different treatment. It was often present before surgery but less noticeable. In the first few weeks, an eyelid may also temporarily sit lower because of swelling. If it still sits noticeably lower over your pupil after a few months, discuss it with your surgeon.

    Dry eyes and difficulty closing your eyes

    After eyelid surgery, your eyes may feel dry or irritated for a while, or as if there’s sand in them. Sometimes they water more than usual. In an American study of 892 upper or lower eyelid surgeries, about a quarter of patients reported dry eye symptoms. The rate is probably lower after upper eyelid surgery alone. Symptoms are usually temporary. Swelling can prevent your eyelids from closing fully, and you may blink less, causing tears to evaporate from your eyes more quickly.


    In the long term, dry-eye symptoms did not worsen on average after upper eyelid surgery, and sometimes even improved. This was shown in a 2025 review of well-designed studies. However, the eye was more likely to remain slightly open when a strip of muscle was removed along with the skin.


    What you can do: use the drops or ointment you were given, take regular breaks from screen work, and don’t rub your eyes. If you already had dry eyes or have had laser eye surgery, you’re more likely to have symptoms. If you’re still considering surgery, tell your surgeon beforehand. If your eyes are still dry after six weeks, have them assessed. If an eye that doesn’t close properly becomes painful, red or blurry, don’t wait—call immediately.

    The scar: red, raised or bumpy

    With upper eyelid surgery, the scar sits in the natural crease of the eyelid. This makes it barely visible when your eyes are open. It will be red and sometimes a little raised during the first few weeks. Small bumps or blisters along the scar can also occur. They often form around the stitches and usually disappear on their own.


    A scar takes months to flatten and fade. What still stands out after six weeks is often a thin, pale line after six months. A raised scar on the eyelid is rare. Protect it from the sun with sunglasses for the first few months. Ask your surgeon when you can apply sunscreen to the scar.


    If the scar remains raised or red for months, or feels tight, there is often something that can be done. A minor scar revision is usually only carried out once the scar has fully settled.

    If your heavy-looking eyes return: look at your eyebrows

    Sometimes the reason for regret is above the eyelid: the eyebrow. Many people’s eyebrows droop with age, especially at the outer edges. Without realizing it, they raise their eyebrows using their forehead to see better. After eyelid surgery, they need to do this less. In some people, the forehead then relaxes and the eyebrows drop slightly.


    A 2023 review of studies found that, on average, the eyebrow sits almost 1.5 millimetres lower after upper eyelid surgery. For someone whose eyebrows are already drooping, this can bring back some of the heavy, tired look. This may feel like a failed procedure, even though the eyelids themselves were treated successfully.


    That’s why a good doctor will also assess your eyebrow position before eyelid surgery. Sometimes eyebrow surgery is a better option, or a combination of procedures may be needed. If the outer part of the eyebrow is slightly drooping, a wrinkle-relaxing treatment can sometimes lift it by a few millimetres temporarily. This is also known as a non-surgical brow lift. The effect lasts a few months and is not a substitute for surgery. The doctor must be precise, because injecting in the wrong place on the forehead can make the eyebrow droop instead.

    What you can do if you regret your decision

    Unsure about the result? Here’s what you can do.


    1. Call your clinic first. Tell them what you can see and feel. A surgeon can quickly tell you whether it’s part of a normal recovery. That’s what follow-up appointments are for.


    2. Keep track of your recovery with photos. Take a photo from the front each week, with your eyes open and closed, in the same lighting. Put your before-surgery photos next to them. This lets you see whether the difference is getting smaller and gives your surgeon something to compare.


    3. Give it time. Don’t assess the final result until three to six months after surgery.


    4. Ask for a second opinion if the discussion does not help. Another doctor can review your eyes, your photos and the operation report.


    5. Make a complaint if you feel you are not being taken seriously. Every healthcare provider in the Netherlands must have a complaints procedure and a complaints officer who can help you free of charge. The clinic must also be affiliated with a dispute resolution body. It can issue a binding decision and award compensation. Cosmopolitan Clinic refers patients to Dokh, an organisation for healthcare complaints and disputes.


    It’s best not to compare your situation with other people’s photos online. You don’t know which week they were taken or what their eyes looked like before surgery.

    Can eyelid surgery be revised?

    Often, yes, depending on the issue. If there is excess skin, the surgeon can remove another small strip. A scar that remains raised or pulls can usually be improved. Differences between the left and right eyelid creases can often be adjusted too.


    It’s more difficult if too much skin has been removed. Skin that’s gone does not grow back. A skin graft or another approach may be needed. This is work for a specialist eyelid surgeon. So the surgery can’t be reversed, but the result can often be improved.


    For almost every revision, the rule is: wait first. Tissue that is still healing is swollen and does not respond well to another procedure. That’s why revision surgery is usually done only after three to six months, when everything has settled. One exception is an eye that cannot close well enough, causing damage to the cornea, the clear front surface of the eye. In that case, the surgeon may need to intervene sooner.

    How to avoid regrets: what to discuss beforehand

    A study of nearly 600 people in the Netherlands found that satisfaction after eyelid surgery is closely linked to how people feel about their decision in hindsight. That’s why it’s important to make an informed choice. Ask these questions during your consultation:



    Is my heavy-looking appearance caused by excess eyelid skin, a drooping eyebrow or both?

    Could my eyelid itself be sitting too low (ptosis)?

    How much skin will you remove, and will you also remove any fat or muscle? Why or why not?

    Do I have dry eyes or other eye problems that could make recovery more difficult?

    Do I take blood thinners or supplements that increase the risk of bleeding?

    What difference can I expect, and what won’t this procedure address, such as under-eye bags or crow’s feet?

    What happens if I’m not happy after six months, and what would a revision cost?


    Take your time deciding and don’t let anyone rush you. Read more about what to look for when choosing a clinic and doctor in our blog about choosing the best eyelid surgery in Amsterdam. Find out what the procedure involves and what recovery is like on our eyelid surgery page.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    When will I see the final result of my eyelid surgery?

    Most of the swelling goes down within one to two weeks. You won’t see the final result for three to six months. After that, the scar will continue to fade gradually.

    Is it normal for my eyes to look strange after a week?

    That’s very common. Swelling can make the crease look higher and more defined. The swelling is also rarely the same on both sides, so your eyes may look uneven. This usually improves on its own over the following weeks.

    Can eyelid surgery be reversed?

    Removed skin does not grow back. The result can often be adjusted, for example if there is excess skin or the scar remains raised or red. This is usually done only after three to six months.

    Are most people happy with their eyelid surgery?

    In a large Dutch study, people were significantly more satisfied with their eyelids six months after surgery than before, and this remained the case after a year. In an American study, around 4 percent had repeat surgery, usually because some excess skin remained.

    How long will my eyes stay dry after eyelid surgery?

    For most people, dry or irritated eyes improve as the swelling goes down. Use the drops or ointment you were given. If symptoms last longer than six weeks, have them assessed. If an eye that doesn’t close properly becomes painful or red, get it checked right away.

    Where can I make a complaint about my eyelid surgery?

    Start with the clinic where you had treatment. Every healthcare provider must have a complaints procedure and a complaints officer. If that doesn’t resolve the issue, you can contact the dispute resolution body the clinic is affiliated with.

    Sources

    • Six months after upper eyelid surgery, significantly greater satisfaction with eyes and eyelids; people estimated their age to be an average of 3.3 years younger; no clinically relevant change between six and twelve months (2,134 participants). Source: Domela Nieuwenhuis I et al., Aesthetic Surgery Journal 2022;42(4):340-348 (prospective multicentre cohort study).
    • Satisfaction with the result is strongly associated with the decision to have surgery and satisfaction with appearance after surgery (583 participants). Source: Luong KP et al., Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Global Open 2023;11(9):e5260 (cohort study).
    • 3.8 percent revision rate after upper eyelid surgery without ptosis repair, usually because excess skin remained (533 procedures in 278 patients). Source: Falcon Rodriguez L et al., Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 2024, doi 10.1097/PRS.0000000000011324 (Mayo Clinic retrospective study).
    • Dry eye symptoms in 26.5 percent of 892 upper and/or lower eyelid surgeries. Source: Prischmann J et al., JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery 2013;15(1):39-46 (retrospective study).
    • Dry eye symptoms are, on average, no worse after upper eyelid surgery and sometimes improve; incomplete eyelid closure is more common when muscle is also removed. Source: Functional and Aesthetic Outcomes After Upper Blepharoplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Control Trials, Aesthetic Surgery Journal 2025;45(6):554-562 (meta-analysis).
    • The eyebrow sits an average of about 1.45 millimeters lower after upper eyelid surgery. Source: Aesthetic Plastic Surgery 2023, doi 10.1007/s00266-023-03288-0 (systematic review and meta-analysis).
    • Bleeding behind the eye after eyelid surgery occurs in approximately 0.055 percent of cases. Source: Hass AN et al., Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 2004;20(6):426-432.
    • Loss of vision after eyelid surgery occurs in about 1 in 20,000 cases, and is permanent in about 1 in 30,000. Source: Mejia JD, Egro FM, Nahai F, Aesthetic Surgery Journal 2011;31(1):21-29 (review).
    • Stitches removed after 5 to 7 days, about three months for all swelling to go away, mild asymmetry is normal, small blisters near the stitches usually disappear on their own. Source: Upper eyelid surgery patient leaflet, St. Antonius Hospital.
    • Complaints procedure, free complaints officer and membership of a recognised dispute resolution body are mandatory for healthcare providers. Source: Dutch Healthcare Quality, Complaints and Disputes Act (Wkkgz).
    • Surgery process, swelling and bruising within one to two weeks, skin healed after six weeks, referral to Dokh for concerns. Source: cosmopolitanclinic.nl, eyelid surgery page (clinic’s own information, November 2026).

    Personalised advice

    Considering eyelid surgery and want to know if it is right for you? During a consultation at our clinic in Amsterdam, the doctor will assess your eyelids and eyebrows. They will also discuss what you hope to achieve and what surgery can and cannot do for you. Have you already had eyelid surgery and are unsure about the result? You are welcome to come in for a consultation too. Book a no-obligation consultation.